20 Pack Extra Thick Magic Cleaning Pads - Eraser Sponge for All Surfaces - Kitchen-Bathroom-Furniture-Leather-Car-Steel - Just Add Water to Erase All Dirt - Melamine - Universal Cleaner

I like that theyre theyre thick and really work. I usually throw them out after about 4 uses, not because you cant use them anymore, but because I personally dont like used sponges. If youre using them to scrub food stains off your counter or yellow stains in your tubs, itll do the job quite well. The sponge does get yellow after scrubbing the stains which is what grosses me out and makes me toss them. If thats not a problem for you though, theyll last you a while. I dont notice any disintegration, but occasionally they will tear. I havent used any melamine sponges before so I dont have a great point of reference, but Ive had a good experience with these so I will keep buying them.

I used this for less than 10 minutes and it fell apart. Definitely could not be used for tough jobs

If you love Mr. Clean magic erasers, then I seriously suggest giving these a shot. I don’t find them quite as durable long term (still pretty durable), but they are substantially cheaper. There is literally nothing these little wonders can’t handle. For example, did I spill honey (curry, red wine, warmed wax melts - I’m prone to spilling things) on my counter and was lazy and didn’t clean it till morning? Yes, I did. And this little worker was all, “NBD, I got you!” Also super great on walls and doors. Gets the dirt off, while keeping the paint safe. If one spot gets too worn, I just cut off that worn piece and keep on using. I absolutely love this product!

Cleans most services Not wood Add water and go hardly any pressure and all comes clean

I was looking for a chemical free cleaner that performed well. I tried and liked Mr. Clean Magic Eraser but was disappointed by how quickly it fell apart. Decided to try the STP alternate and found them to be a superior product over the Magic Eraser. STP lasted 3x as long and did not crumble as quickly or as badly as the Magic Eraser. Do Realize, both wear out rather quickly. Both worked well for me on certain tasks and horrible on other task. Both performed best when getting the sponge wet (not just the surface being cleaned) and rince the sponge often. Both products removed old stains that other cleaners (fantastic, vinegar & water, soft scrub) didnt. Both sponges did well cleaning: 1. Plastic tub & shower walls 2 Wood cabinets 3. Floor Tile (ceramic & vinyl) 4. Grime off metal & wood doors 5. Plastic deck rails Neither sponge did well cleaning: 1. Old Grease off kitchen stove 2. Old Grease & grime off kitchen tile behind stove 3. Glass stove top

These are thicker than the erasers. The first time I used one a huge chunk fell off. I will continue using them, but I wont repurchase. Ill go back to the name brand next time.

I waited until Id used half the pack to make a decision on these. Ive never used the name brand Magic Erasers, so I cant compare to those. These are incredible for cleaning oil-based messes, such as in the kitchen. These tore through the greasy film on my stovetop and oven so well. These provide a level of clean that I normally feel that I can only get from scrubbing something with baking soda. Theyre transformative on plastic-based materials--the handle on my fridge and oven have never felt cleaner! These are amazing for getting the oil-based grime that accumulates in places that we touch a lot. For example, I thought my cabinets were clean. I give them a little wipe down with a washcloth about once a week, for reference. But the levels of grime I was able to scrub off my laminate cabinets uses these sponges was shocking. I clean them regularly! But these are great for deep down cleaning and getting that base layer of oily mess that can accumulate in the kitchen. Cons: They definitely disintegrate as you use them, and depending on what youre cleaning, you might be making a mess as youre trying to clean one up. When I used these for cleaning my oven hood (worked SO WELL), I put a towel on my stove top, to catch the balled up pieces of sponge that roll off. But I find it less mess than trying to use baking soda, especially on vertical surfaces. Id definitely buy these again. Im down to half a pack, but my house feels so deep down clean now that I dont know how quickly Ill be going through the second half! :)

I love that these are extra thick. I actually cut them in half with a kitchen knife so they are easier to handle. They also seem to last a bit longer than other brands.

Was impressed!

I bought these because I paint, and I would often end up with pigment stains on my paint pallet that I couldnt wash off with any amount of scrubbing. I knew that Magic Eraser sponges were great for removing stains, but I was looking for something a bit bigger than the Mr. Clean ones, as theyre very small, and dont last long at all. I looked up what the Magic Eraser sponges were made out of, and found out that Mr. Cleans Magic Eraser is literally just a Melamine Sponge with a little bit of Mr. Clean cleaning agent in it, but the Melamine Sponge is the part of the item that does the Magic Erasing. So instead of paying 12 dollars for a 10-pack of Mr. Cleans Magic Erasers, I looked up Melamine Sponges and found this 20-pack of sponges that are TWICE AS THICK as Mr. Cleans, and so will last twice as long. They remove the pigment stains from my paint pallet and the handles of my brushes in LITERALLY 1 SWIPE, and because I dont have to scrub anything with very much pressure at all, these things dont fall apart very easily at all, and I imagine that one of these will probably last me a month or more (if I only use it to clean my painting equipment, that is) All in all, I give these an A+