Dove Refillable Deodorant Starter Kit 0% Aluminum Cucumber & Green Tea Aluminum Free Deodorant 1.13 oz

On the Yuka app this products ingredients are rated as hazardous. Mind you I expect this with most deodorants, but I was hopeful with the promise of zero aluminum. The deodorant stick does not stay on the insert. It falls off so between it being harmful and ineffective I rate this -10

Este producto tiene un defecto que no permite cerrar bien la tapa. Se abre muy fácilmente y no encaja como debería. Ni pensar llevarlo a un viaje. Más que un desodorante es un artículo de decoración. La idea de cartuchos es buena pero les falto trabajar un poco en la calidad. Los materiales son muy buenos y se ven elegantes pero su funcionalidad es muy deficiente. Por lo menos por ir a regresar el producto sin oler mal. ;)

Should have listened to all the other reviewers... design is so bad that the whole thing just falls apart as you use it.

The product didn’t even last two weeks without the deodorant part breaking. Ended up buying my usual. Waste of money.

Used twice then broke off. Nothing to hold the deodorant in place and falls right off. Neat idea. Bad design

Yes the sent is amazing it’s a great idea but the product design itself is faulty. the entire deodorant that you use sticks out so it gets scraped with the cap if you’re not careful. The cap doesn’t stay on in a bag. And After 6 uses the stick broke off of the bottom part of the case. I had to use my hand to put it on. Ans buy a new deodorant. I didn’t use any crazy force.

I’ve used the original aluminum formula for years that works great but has caused me irritation. So I tried this 0% formula and it only lasts a few hours. Plus, the stick started coming off the base and I was extra gentle in applying because of other reviews saying it falls off. Needs LOTS of improvements.

I’ve been looking forever for a deodorant with BOTH environmentally responsible packaging AND socially acceptable body odor control that won’t leave me either wanting to die at the audacity of my own pit odor or sincerely alarmed at the virulence of the rising pit rash at the end of each day, and thought I had FINALLY found the holy grail in this product from a brand that has otherwise always been reliable for me. Alas, no. On second use, deodorant completely sheared off the insert platform and went skittering under the sink of my hotel bathroom, picking up every single speck of grit, wisp of pubic hair and errant toenail clipping that it encountered along the way. I had to fish it out from under the cabinet, scrape off about half the product and then use my bare hands to mash what was left back down onto the insert, only to have it break off again the minute I tried to re-apply. After retrieving again, scraping off the gross parts for a second time only to fail AGAIN, I ended up just breaking off a chunk with my hand and just kind of attempting to smear it into my armpit- a no for me, thanks. A great idea from a usually reliable brand, but, unfortunately, until they get the usability right, I won’t be putting myself through that again.

The lid comes off and the insert comes out. My purse has more deodorant than me! I even keep it in that small pocket for like a phone or something and it comes open all the time. The smell isnt as great as I hoped. Its very sticky and leaves a weird residue even after showers I feel like its still there. Not for me but with that said my teens love the ones I bought them. I dont think they are worth the money compared to just a regular stick of dove (which I use)

Love the scent, formula, sleek metal container… product execution failed miserably. There is no option to roll product up and down with every use so by the second or third use, the whole product breaks off from its base. Hopefully they come up with a fix because it really is a great formula and idea!